Skip to main content

On Free Speech (Sima Qian)

王行暴虐侈傲,国人谤王。召公谏曰:“民不堪命矣。”王怒,得卫巫,使监谤者,以告则杀之。其谤鲜矣,诸侯不朝。三十四年,王益严,国人莫敢言,道路以目。厉王喜,告召公曰:“吾能弭谤矣,乃不敢言。”召公曰:“是鄣之也。防民之口,甚於防水。水壅而溃,伤人必多,民亦如之。是故为水者决之使导,为民者宣之使言。故天子听政,使公卿至於列士献诗,瞽献曲,史献书,师箴,瞍赋,蒙诵,百工谏,庶人传语,近臣尽规,亲戚补察,瞽史教诲,耆艾修之,而后王斟酌焉,是以事行而不悖。民之有口也,犹土之有山川也,财用於是乎出:犹其有原隰衍沃也,衣食於是乎生。口之宣言也,善败於是乎兴。行善而备败,所以产财用衣食者也。夫民虑之於心而宣之於口,成而行之。若壅其口,其与能几何?”王不听。於是国莫敢出言,三年,乃相与畔,袭厉王。厉王出奔於彘。

The king was tyrannical, extravagant, and proud, so the people of his country slandered him. The Duke of Shao reproved him, saying: "Truly, the people cannot bear your rule."  The king became angry and got Wei-Wu to serve as his Inspector of Slander, so that whoever he accused of it was slain. After that, the slanders became few, and the nobles did not go to court.  

In the 34th year, the king became even more severe, and none of the people of his country dared speak, only exchanging glances as they crossed the road.  King Li was happy, and to the Duke of Shao he pronounced, "Truly I am capable of quelling these slanders, for none dare speak." 

The Duke of Shao then said, "This is simply to obstruct the slander. Stopping the mouths of the people is more serious than damming water. For when water becomes stopped up and then bursts, certainly many are injured; with the people it is [worse].  For this reason, who would control water must use channels to keep it from overflowing, and who would control the people must use words to keep them from venting. 

Thus the Son of Heaven holds court, making ministers, dukes, and knights offer poems, the blind (1) songs, the historians books, the masters exhortations, those without pupils (?) prose poems, the idiots (?) recitations, the hundred craftsmen recommendations, the commoners reports, the courtiers regulations, relatives corrections, the ministers of astrology and music admonitions, the elders tuition (?) -- whereupon the king will ponder all these things in order to implement, not rebut them.

The people have speech in the way that the earth has mountains and streams, because advantage comes from it. For example, having plains and marshes, it becomes fertile, from which arise food and clothing. The declarations of the mouth whether of good or ill bring prosperity. For we implement what is good and prepare for what is ill, by which means we produce goods, food, and clothing. Thus what the people agitate over in their hearts and announce with their mouths, bring it about and practice it. But if you stop up their mouths, how can you accomplish this?"

The king did not heed him, and thus none in the country dared speak for three years, whereupon there was a gathering at the borders, and King Li was attacked. King Li then fled to the country of Zhi.

1. "In ancient times, blind men were ministers of music, for which reason 'blind' became an abbreviation for the name of that office."

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Sample Essay On Shakespeare's Fifth Sonnet (For My Students)

The theme of Shakespeare’s 5 th Sonnet is saving time. In the poem, Shakespeare talks about how time makes beautiful things ugly. He compares growing old to the way that summer changes into winter. Though in the summer there are many beautiful flowers, in the winter all of these beautiful flowers are gone and there is “bareness every where” (8). The winter is so empty that we could almost forget there had ever been flowers at all – if we didn’t “distil” (13) the beauty of summer to make perfume. What Shakespeare means is that we need to find a way to remember being young (the summer) so that when we are older (in winter) we will still be able to remember being happy. We could do this by having children, who will look like us and make us remember who we were when we were young. I just explained the theme of Shakespeare’s poem and summarized the poem. Now I will talk about how he communicates his theme. First, Shakespeare uses metonymy to help us understand how beautiful we ar...

Genre -- In General

I've spent a bit of time recently watching YouTube videos related to the question of what makes something an RPG.  Since studying literary theory in college, I've become skeptical that you can give clean-cut definitions of the various genres.  I think two works belong to the same genre if they are similar enough across various dimensions.  The problem with similarity is that it's vague.  Everything is similar to everything else in some way, just on a general metaphysical level, and once you get to the products of human culture, each of them is much more like each of the others than it is different.  So arguments about genre tend to fixate on arbitrarily selected differences the importance of which are then magnified to the level of dogma. I believe there is no one difference that will always make X a member of genre G rather than genre G'.  The products of culture are descriptively rich, and there are any number of relevant features that make our experien...

An Empty Gesture

He finds that with propriety he cannot write about his own life.  He acts against people, but he would not make those people conscious witnesses of his actions.  He seals himself away from others, both by the barriers he places in their way and by the silence he erects to guard those barriers.  It is the assault of an animal -- the very thought is contained in the action, and the thought is nothing besides, or at least has no other expression than, that action. To the departed: it was a matter of drifting, it was a matter of harm.  The harm became a wound, the wound scarred, the scar is a rift.  I think of it like a gap that fills up with all the hostilities of the world.  It is something radical and diseased, and I want no part of it.  I also would like to be someone else.  There is now what is for me an insurmountable investment of pain required to cross it, so I would rather call it a loss.  But I feel the pain enough to remark it. ...